The years that saw the founding of Cornell and Stanford Universities were also the years when many small private colleges...
GMAT Reading Comprehension : (RC) Questions
The years that saw the founding of Cornell and Stanford Universities were also the years when many small private colleges were established in the Southern U.S. to serve the educational needs of the newly freed slaves. While great 19th century industrial entrepreneurs like Ezra Cornell and Leland Stanford gave amounts ranging from half a million to tens of millions of dollars to found great private teaching and research universities where none had previously existed, and while many others, less famous, gave impressive sums to expand and refurbish modest college establishments that had already taken root, there were not comparable benefactions for private Black higher educational institutions. Only in the 20th century, and then mostly through the donations of a handful of individuals and bodies like the General Education Board of the Rockefeller Foundation and the Julius Rosenwald Fund, did the struggling private Black institutions begin to receive support in single-gift amounts larger than a few thousand dollars.
A similar disparity existed between Black and White state-supported institutions. The Morrill Act of 1862 is considered by some to be the most important piece of federal legislation affecting state-supported higher education in the 19th century. It created the basis on which states established land-grant institutions throughout the country, most successfully perhaps in the midwestern States. Less has been written about the Morrill Act of 1890, which made possible the establishment of separate Black land-grant institutions in the southern and border states, where the majority of Black people lived before the 1st World War. Though it is called the "2nd Morrill Act", no one would seriously contend that it achieved monetarily for Black land-grant institutions anything comparable to what the 1862 legislation accomplished for other land-grant institutions. The "separate but equal" principle, even if it had been faithfully adhered to, could never have created black land-grant institutions in the southern and border states as financially secure as the land-grant institutions that developed with the help of the 1862 act: these states simply were not generous in their appropriations for state-supported education. So long as college education was uncommon (which it was until well into the twentieth century) and so long as even high school education was not an occupational requirement (note that only about fifteen percent of the age group fourteen to seventeen was enrolled in high school even as late as 1910), it was possible to ignore the very substantial differences that existed between the educational opportunities available to White people and those available to Black people. After the Second World War, high school and college education became common among White Youth while the overwhelming majority of Black youth were still excluded from the college option. It was then that the full extent of the financial discrimination against Black higher educational institutions became apparent.
The author connects the timing of the establishment of many small private Black colleges in the South to which of the following events?
1. Passage Analysis:
Progressive Passage Analysis
Text from Passage | Analysis |
---|---|
The years that saw the founding of Cornell and Stanford Universities were also the years when many small private colleges were established in the Southern U.S. to serve the educational needs of the newly freed slaves. | What it says: Two things happened at the same time in the late 1800s: famous universities like Cornell and Stanford were founded, and small colleges for formerly enslaved people were established in the South. What it does: Sets up a time period and introduces two different types of educational institutions being founded simultaneously. Source/Type: Historical fact Connection to Previous Sentences: This is the opening sentence, establishing our foundation. Visualization: Timeline (late 1800s): • Big famous universities (Cornell, Stanford) = Founded • Small Southern colleges for freed slaves = Also founded Reading Strategy Insight: The author signals a comparison coming with "were also the years when" - watch for contrasts between these two types of institutions. What We Know So Far: Two different educational developments happened simultaneously What We Don't Know Yet: How these two developments differed in support or outcomes |
2. Passage Summary:
Author's Purpose:
To trace the historical development of funding disparities in higher education and explain how these long-standing inequalities became an obvious social problem when education became important for economic success.
3. Question Analysis:
The question asks what event the author connects to the timing of when many small private Black colleges were established in the South. This is asking for a direct cause-and-effect relationship that the author explicitly states in the passage.
Connecting to Our Passage Analysis:
From our passage analysis, the very first sentence provides the key connection: "The years that saw the founding of Cornell and Stanford Universities were also the years when many small private colleges were established in the Southern U.S. to serve the educational needs of the newly freed slaves."
Prethinking:
The author makes an explicit, direct connection in the very first sentence. The establishment of small private Black colleges in the South happened during the same period as the founding of major universities like Cornell and Stanford, and these colleges were created "to serve the educational needs of the newly freed slaves." The phrase "newly freed slaves" clearly indicates that emancipation was the driving event that created the educational need these colleges were established to address. The timing and purpose are both directly stated - no inference required.
Why It's Right:
- The passage directly states these colleges were established "to serve the educational needs of the newly freed slaves"
- "Newly freed slaves" explicitly refers to emancipation as the event that created the educational need
- The author makes this connection in the very first sentence, establishing it as foundational to the entire discussion
- The timing aligns perfectly - late 1800s when Cornell/Stanford were founded matches the post-Civil War emancipation period
Key Evidence: "The years that saw the founding of Cornell and Stanford Universities were also the years when many small private colleges were established in the Southern U.S. to serve the educational needs of the newly freed slaves."
Why It's Wrong:
- The passage never mentions a Morrill Act in 1892 - this date doesn't appear anywhere
- The passage discusses the 1862 Morrill Act and 1890 Morrill Act, but not 1892
- Private Black colleges mentioned in the question were established much earlier than 1892
Common Student Mistakes:
- Did you confuse the 1890 Morrill Act date with 1892? → Review the passage carefully - it states 1890, not 1892
- Are you thinking the Morrill Acts created private colleges? → The Morrill Acts created land-grant (public) institutions, not private colleges
Why It's Wrong:
- The 1890 Morrill Act dealt with land-grant institutions (public colleges), not private colleges
- The question asks about small private colleges, but the 1890 Act established separate Black land-grant institutions
- The timing doesn't match - private Black colleges were established earlier than 1890
Common Student Mistakes:
- Are you confusing private and public institutions? → Private colleges (mentioned in the question) were funded by donations; land-grant institutions were government-supported
- Did you focus on Black educational institutions without noting the private vs. public distinction? → The Morrill Acts specifically addressed public land-grant colleges, not private institutions
Why It's Wrong:
- High school enrollment increases happened much later than the establishment of these private colleges
- The passage indicates only 15% of teens were in high school as late as 1910, well after these colleges were founded
- The increase in Black high school attendance would come even later than white attendance
Common Student Mistakes:
- Are you thinking about educational progression logically (high school before college)? → While logical, the historical timeline shows these colleges were established before widespread high school attendance
- Did you focus on educational statistics without checking the chronology? → The 15% high school enrollment figure from 1910 shows this increase came after college establishment
Why It's Wrong:
- These foundations provided support much later than the initial establishment of the colleges
- The passage states foundations like Rockefeller only began supporting Black institutions "in the 20th century"
- The colleges were established in the late 1800s to serve newly freed slaves, before these foundations existed
Common Student Mistakes:
- Are you confusing initial establishment with later support? → The question asks about timing of establishment, not when colleges received major funding
- Did the mention of specific foundation names make this seem more concrete? → Specific names can be distracting, but check the timeline - these came much later