Loading...
The number of applications for teaching positions in Newtown's public schools was 5.7 percent lower in 1993 than in 1985 and 5.9 percent lower in 1994 than in 1985. Despite a steadily growing student population and an increasing number of teacher resignations, however, Newtown did not face a teacher shortage in the late 1990's.
Which of the following, if true, would contribute most to an explanation of the apparent discrepancy above?
| Text from Passage | Analysis |
| The number of applications for teaching positions in Newtown's public schools was \(5.7\%\) lower in 1993 than in 1985 and \(5.9\%\) lower in 1994 than in 1985. |
|
| Despite a steadily growing student population and an increasing number of teacher resignations, however, Newtown did not face a teacher shortage in the late 1990's. |
|
The passage presents what seems like an impossible situation. We start with declining teacher applications, then learn that student numbers were growing and teacher resignations were increasing - all factors that should create a teacher shortage. But then we're told no shortage actually happened. This creates a mystery that needs explaining.
There's an apparent discrepancy - Newtown should have had a teacher shortage given all the negative factors, but somehow didn't experience one in the late 1990s.
This isn't a traditional argument with premises supporting a conclusion. Instead, it's a puzzle presentation. The author is saying 'Here are facts that don't seem to fit together logically' and asking us to figure out what could explain this seeming contradiction. The logical structure is: Problem factors + Unexpected outcome = Need for explanation.
Paradox - We need to resolve the apparent contradiction between declining applications + growing student population + increasing resignations versus no teacher shortage occurring
Quantitative claims about application percentages (\(5.7\%\) and \(5.9\%\) decreases), qualitative claims about student population growth and resignation increases, and the definitive claim that no shortage occurred in late 1990s
For paradox questions, we need to find information that explains how all the given facts can be true simultaneously. We're looking for factors that could offset the negative trends (fewer applications, more students, more resignations) to prevent a teacher shortage. We cannot question any of the stated facts - applications did decline, student population did grow, resignations did increase, and no shortage did occur.