In 1975 Chinese survey teams remeasured Mount Everest, the highest of the Himalayan mountains. Like the British in 1852, they...
GMAT Reading Comprehension : (RC) Questions
In 1975 Chinese survey teams remeasured Mount Everest, the highest of the Himalayan mountains. Like the British in 1852, they used the age-old technique of "carrying in" sea level: surveyors marched inland from the coast for thousands of miles, stopping at increments of as little as a few feet to measure their elevation, and marking each increment with two poles. To measure the difference in elevation between poles, surveyors used an optical level—a telescope on a level base—placed halfway between the poles. They sighted each pole, reading off measurements that were then used to calculate the change in elevation over each increment. In sight of the peaks they used theodolites—telescopes for measuring vertical and horizontal angles to determine the elevation of the summit.
The Chinese, however, made efforts to correct for the errors that had plagued the British. One source of error is refraction, the bending of light beams as they pass through air layers of different temperature and pressure. Because light traveling down from a summit passes through many such layers, a surveyor could sight a mirage rather than the peak itself. To reduce refraction errors, the Chinese team carried in sea level to within five to twelve miles of Everest's summit, decreasing the amount of air that light passed through on its way to their theodolites. The Chinese also launched weather balloons near their theodolites to measure atmospheric temperature and pressure changes to better estimate refraction errors. Another hurdle is the peak's shape. When surveyors sight the summit, there is a risk they might not all measure the same point. In 1975 the Chinese installed the first survey beacon on Everest, a red reflector visible through a theodolite for ten miles, as a reference point. One more source of error is the unevenness of sea level. The British assumed that carrying in sea level would extend an imaginary line from the shore along Earth's curve to a point beneath the Himalaya. In reality, sea level varies according to the irregular interior of the planet. The Chinese used a gravity meter to correct for local deviations in sea level.
It can be inferred from the passage that refraction would be most likely to cause errors in measurements of a mountain's elevation under which of the following conditions?
1. Passage Analysis:
Progressive Passage Analysis
Text from Passage | Analysis |
---|---|
In 1975 Chinese survey teams remeasured Mount Everest, the highest of the Himalayan mountains. | What it says: Chinese teams measured Mount Everest's height again in 1975. What it does: Sets up the main topic and timeframe Source/Type: Historical fact Connection to Previous Sentences: This is our opening - establishes the foundation Visualization: Timeline: 1975 → Chinese teams → Mount Everest measurement project Reading Strategy Insight: Simple, clear opening. We know WHAT happened and WHEN. What We Know So Far: Chinese teams measured Everest in 1975 What We Don't Know Yet: HOW they measured it, WHY they remeasured it |
• Sea level variations are mentioned as a completely separate error type (Error #3) unrelated to refraction
• The passage explicitly treats "unevenness of sea level" as distinct from refraction problems
• Local sea level variations affect the baseline measurement, not light bending through air
• Humidity is never mentioned in the passage as a factor affecting refraction
• The passage specifically identifies "temperature and pressure" as the air conditions that cause light bending
• This introduces information not supported by the text
• This contradicts the passage, which states that being far from the peak INCREASES refraction errors
• The Chinese solution was to get CLOSER (5-12 miles) specifically to reduce refraction
• The passage shows that distance increases the amount of air light passes through
• The passage explicitly states that Chinese used weather balloons to measure "atmospheric temperature and pressure changes to better estimate refraction errors"
• This directly connects temperature and pressure variations to refraction problems
• Low temperature and pressure would represent significant atmospheric changes that cause light bending
• The fact that Chinese needed to measure these conditions shows they directly affect refraction accuracy
• This describes the Chinese SOLUTION to refraction, not a condition that would cause errors
• Being within 5-12 miles was specifically designed to REDUCE refraction errors
• This choice confuses the improvement with the original problem