Loading...
A certain telephone company offers two plans, A and B. Under plan A, the company charges a total of $0.60 for the first 7 minutes of each call and $0.06 per minute thereafter. Under plan B, the company charges $0.08 per minute of each call. What is the duration of a call, in minutes, for which the company charges the same amount under plan A and under plan B?
Let's understand what each plan charges in plain English:
Plan A works like a taxi fare - there's a base charge plus extra for additional time. You pay \(\$0.60\) no matter what for the first 7 minutes of your call. If your call goes longer than 7 minutes, you pay an additional \(\$0.06\) for every minute beyond those first 7 minutes.
Plan B is simpler - it's like paying by the minute for everything. You pay \(\$0.08\) for every single minute you talk, from the very first minute.
We need to find the exact call length where both plans cost exactly the same amount.
Process Skill: TRANSLATE - Converting the word problem into clear mathematical understanding before setting up equations
Now let's express what each plan costs for a call of 't' minutes.
For Plan B, this is straightforward: Cost = \(\$0.08 \times \mathrm{t}\)
For Plan A, we need to consider two scenarios:
- If the call is 7 minutes or less: Cost = \(\$0.60\)
- If the call is longer than 7 minutes: Cost = \(\$0.60 + \$0.06 \times \text{(extra minutes beyond 7)}\)
For calls longer than 7 minutes, if the total call is 't' minutes, then the extra minutes are \(\left(\mathrm{t} - 7\right)\).
So for calls over 7 minutes: Plan A cost = \(\$0.60 + \$0.06 \times \left(\mathrm{t} - 7\right)\)
Since we're looking for when the costs are equal, let's check if this happens for short calls (7 minutes or less) or longer calls.
For a 7-minute call:
- Plan A: \(\$0.60\) (the base charge)
- Plan B: \(\$0.08 \times 7 = \$0.56\)
Plan A costs more at 7 minutes. Since Plan B's rate (\(\$0.08\)/minute) is higher than Plan A's additional rate (\(\$0.06\)/minute), Plan B will eventually cost more for longer calls. So the equal point must be somewhere beyond 7 minutes.
Process Skill: CONSIDER ALL CASES - Determining which scenario applies before solving
Since the answer must be for calls longer than 7 minutes, we set the costs equal:
Plan A cost = Plan B cost
\(\$0.60 + \$0.06 \times \left(\mathrm{t} - 7\right) = \$0.08 \times \mathrm{t}\)
Let's solve this step by step:
\(\$0.60 + \$0.06\mathrm{t} - \$0.06 \times 7 = \$0.08\mathrm{t}\)
\(\$0.60 + \$0.06\mathrm{t} - \$0.42 = \$0.08\mathrm{t}\)
\(\$0.18 + \$0.06\mathrm{t} = \$0.08\mathrm{t}\)
\(\$0.18 = \$0.08\mathrm{t} - \$0.06\mathrm{t}\)
\(\$0.18 = \$0.02\mathrm{t}\)
\(\mathrm{t} = \$0.18 \div \$0.02 = 9\)
Let's verify: For a 9-minute call:
- Plan A: \(\$0.60 + \$0.06 \times (9-7) = \$0.60 + \$0.06 \times 2 = \$0.60 + \$0.12 = \$0.72\)
- Plan B: \(\$0.08 \times 9 = \$0.72\) ✓
The duration of a call for which both plans charge the same amount is 9 minutes.
The answer is B.
Students often misinterpret "\(\$0.60\) for the first 7 minutes" as meaning you pay \(\$0.60\) per minute for each of the first 7 minutes, rather than understanding it as a flat fee of \(\$0.60\) total for up to 7 minutes of talk time. This leads to setting up completely wrong equations.
Students may not realize that Plan A has two different pricing scenarios: one formula for calls ≤ 7 minutes and another for calls > 7 minutes. They might try to use a single equation for all call durations, missing the "thereafter" condition in the problem.
Even when students understand there are two cases, they might immediately assume the answer falls in the "≤ 7 minutes" case and only set up the equation Plan B = \(\$0.60\), without checking whether this assumption makes sense given the different rates.
When expanding \(\$0.06 \times \left(\mathrm{t} - 7\right)\), students commonly make the error: \(\$0.06\mathrm{t} - \$0.06 \times 7 = \$0.06\mathrm{t} - \$0.42\), but some students incorrectly calculate this as \(\$0.06\mathrm{t} - \$0.07\) or forget to subtract the \(\$0.42\) entirely.
In the step where \(\$0.18 = \$0.08\mathrm{t} - \$0.06\mathrm{t}\), students often make sign mistakes, such as writing \(\$0.18 = \$0.06\mathrm{t} - \$0.08\mathrm{t} = -\$0.02\mathrm{t}\), leading to a negative answer that should signal an error.
When calculating \(\$0.18 \div \$0.02 = 9\), students frequently make arithmetic mistakes with decimal division, getting answers like 0.9, 90, or 3.6 instead of the correct answer of 9.
Students may arrive at \(\mathrm{t} = 9\) but fail to substitute back into both original cost formulas to confirm that Plan A and Plan B indeed give the same cost. This verification step would catch any computational errors made during solving.
No likely faltering points in answer selection beyond verification - the question asks for the duration in minutes, and if calculated correctly, 9 minutes directly corresponds to choice B.