Two amateur wrestling squads—Squad A and Squad B—competed against each other. Each squad had the same (nonzero) number of its...
GMAT Multi Source Reasoning : (MSR) Questions
Two amateur wrestling squads—Squad A and Squad B—competed against each other. Each squad had the same (nonzero) number of its members who were contestants. In the competition, each contestant in Squads A and B wrestled against exactly one contestant in the other squad, and no non-contestant member of either squad wrestled. Let \(\mathrm{x}\) be the proportion of Squad A's members who were contestants in the competition and let \(\mathrm{y}\) be the proportion of Squad B's members who were contestants in the competition. In terms of \(\mathrm{x}\) and \(\mathrm{y}\) only, what is the proportion of the total number of members in the two squads who were contestants in the competition?
Which one of the following procedures, when applied to the last mathematical expression in the Concise Solution tab, gives a mathematical expression that answers the question asked in the Problem Statement tab?
OWNING THE DATASET
Understanding Source A: Text - Problem Statement
Information from Dataset | Analysis |
---|---|
""Two amateur wrestling squads—Squad A and Squad B—competed against each other. Each squad had the same (nonzero) number of its members who were contestants."" |
|
""In the competition, each contestant in Squads A and B wrestled against exactly one contestant in the other squad"" |
|
""no non-contestant member of either squad wrestled"" |
|
""Let (mathrm{x}) be the proportion of Squad A's members who were contestants...let (mathrm{y}) be the proportion of Squad B's members who were contestants"" |
|
""what is the proportion of the total number of members in the two squads who were contestants in the competition?"" |
|
Summary: Source A sets up a wrestling competition where equal numbers from two squads compete, and asks for a formula to find the overall participation rate in terms of individual squad participation rates (mathrm{x}) and (mathrm{y}).
Understanding Source B: Text - Concise Solution
Information from Dataset | Analysis |
---|---|
""Let (mathrm{a}) and (mathrm{b}) be the number of members of Squad A and Squad B, respectively, and let (mathrm{a'}) and (mathrm{b'}) be the number of contestants"" |
|
""Clearly, (mathrm{a' = xa}) and (mathrm{b' = yb})"" |
|
""Also, (mathrm{xa = yb})"" |
|
""the ratio of the total number of contestants...is (frac{mathrm{xa+yb}}{mathrm{a+b}})"" |
|
""which is equal to (frac{mathrm{2xa}}{mathrm{a+(frac{x}{y})a}})"" |
|
Summary: Source B derives the mathematical solution showing that the overall participation rate equals (frac{mathrm{xa+yb}}{mathrm{a+b}}), which can be simplified using the equal-contestants constraint from Source A.
Understanding Source C: Table
- What the table shows: A 5×5 grid displaying calculated values of (frac{mathrm{xa+yb}}{mathrm{a+b}}) for different combinations of (mathrm{x}) and (mathrm{y}) values
- Key patterns observed:
- Diagonal entries (where (mathrm{x=y})) show values: (frac{1}{4}), (frac{1}{3}), (frac{1}{2}), (frac{2}{3}), (frac{3}{4})
- ""n/p"" entries appear at opposite corners: ((frac{1}{4}, frac{3}{4}))) and ((frac{3}{4}, frac{1}{4})))
- All values range between (frac{1}{4}) and (frac{3}{4})
- Linkage insights:
- To Source A: The table provides practical answers to the problem's question for specific (mathrm{x}) and (mathrm{y}) values
- To Source B: The table contains pre-calculated results using the formula (frac{mathrm{xa+yb}}{mathrm{a+b}}), and the ""n/p"" entries occur where the constraint (mathrm{xa=yb}) cannot be satisfied with reasonable squad sizes
- Key findings:
- When participation rates are equal ((mathrm{x=y})), the overall rate equals that same rate
- Certain (mathrm{x,y}) combinations marked ""n/p"" cannot satisfy the equal-contestants constraint with integer squad sizes
Summary: Source C provides a lookup table for the formula derived in Source B, showing that certain participation rate combinations are impossible due to the equal-contestants constraint from Source A.
Overall Summary
- The wrestling competition problem requires equal numbers of contestants from each squad, creating the mathematical constraint (mathrm{xa = yb})
- This constraint allows us to derive a formula for overall participation rate: (frac{mathrm{xa+yb}}{mathrm{a+b}})
- The lookup table reveals:
- When squads have equal participation rates, the overall rate equals that same rate
- Certain combinations (like (frac{1}{4}) and (frac{3}{4})) are impossible because they can't satisfy the equal-contestants requirement with integer squad sizes
- The overall participation rate is always bounded by the individual squad rates
Question Analysis
- Goal: Find which mathematical operation transforms the expression (frac{2xa}{a+frac{x}{y}a}) into an expression involving only x and y variables, eliminating 'a'
- Key constraints:
- Must eliminate variable 'a'
- Result must be expressed only in terms of x and y
- Result should represent the proportion of contestants
- Answer type needed: Identification of the correct algebraic manipulation procedure
Connecting to Our Passage Analysis
- Analyzing each proposed procedure to determine whether it simplifies the expression to one involving only x and y, without 'a'
- Can be answered from analysis alone through algebraic manipulation of the given expression
Statement Evaluations
Statement 1 Analysis
""Multiply both the numerator and denominator by a.""
- Calculation: (frac{2xa cdot a}{(a + frac{x}{y}a) cdot a} = frac{2xa^2}{a^2 + frac{x}{y}a^2})
- Result: Still contains 'a' and fails to eliminate the variable
- Conclusion: INCORRECT
Statement 2 Analysis
""Multiply both the numerator and denominator by y.""
- Calculation: (frac{2xa cdot y}{(a + frac{x}{y}a) cdot y} = frac{2xay}{ay + xa} = frac{2xy}{x + y})
- Result: Successfully removes 'a' from expression
- Conclusion: CORRECT
Statement 3 Analysis
""Divide both the numerator and denominator by a.""
- Calculation: (frac{2xa / a}{(a + frac{x}{y}a) / a} = frac{2x}{1 + frac{x}{y}} = frac{2xy}{x + y})
- Result: Successfully removes 'a' from expression
- Conclusion: CORRECT
Statement 4 Analysis
""Subtract a and then divide the result a + (x/y)a.""
- This statement is unclear and does not represent a valid algebraic operation on the given expression
- Conclusion: INCORRECT
Statement 5 Analysis
""Divide by a + (x/y)a and then subtract a from the result.""
- This statement describes a sequence of operations that would not eliminate 'a' from the expression
- Conclusion: INCORRECT
Verification
- Options 2 and 3 both simplify the expression to (frac{2xy}{x + y}), eliminating 'a'
- Option 1 keeps 'a' in the expression and therefore fails the requirement
- Option 3 (division by 'a') is the most straightforward and standard method to remove the variable
Answer
Option 3
Multiply both the numerator and denominator by a.
Multiply both the numerator and denominator by y.
Divide both the numerator and denominator by a.
Subtract a and then divide the result \(\mathrm{a + (x/y)a}\).
Divide by \(\mathrm{a + (x/y)a}\) and then subtract a from the result.