Researchers studying long-term changes in regional mouse populations have found that by focusing on the populations of a rare but...
GMAT Multi Source Reasoning : (MSR) Questions
Researchers studying long-term changes in regional mouse populations have found that by focusing on the populations of a rare but widespread and easily identifiable species of mouse (Species X), they can make fairly accurate estimations about the total regional mouse populations.
In a report on a recent study that included the data tables that follow, the researchers provided some addenda:
- The Species X population of Region CV increased by 123,995 between 1990 and 2005.
- In contrast, the Species X population of Region EW declined by about 52% during that same time.
For each of the following statements, select Yes if the statement is accurate based on the information in the passage and tables. Otherwise, select No.
Owning the Dataset
Understanding Source A: Text Source - Research Study
Information from Dataset | Analysis |
---|---|
""Researchers studying long-term changes in regional mouse populations have found that by focusing on the populations of a rare but widespread and easily identifiable species of mouse (Species X), they can make fairly accurate estimations about the total regional mouse populations."" |
|
""The Species X population of Region CV increased by 123,995 between 1990 and 2005."" |
|
""In contrast, the Species X population of Region EW declined by about 52% during that same time."" |
|
- Summary: Research study establishes Species X as a reliable indicator for total mouse populations, with specific examples showing CV region growth and EW region decline between 1990-2005
Understanding Source B: Data Tables - Species X Population Data
- Table Contents:
- Two tables presenting Species X population data across six regions (CV, EW, IQ, JR, PS, TY)
- Three time periods covered: 1960, 1975, 1990
- First table: Absolute population numbers
- Second table: Species X as percentage of total mouse population
- Key Patterns:
- Species X populations range from 20,760 (JR, 1990) to 1,859,460 (IQ, 1960)
- IQ region: Dramatic continuous decline: 1,859,460 → 928,340 → 465,610
- EW region: Stability then growth: 393,260 → 392,080 → 964,020
- Most regions show declining percentages over time
- Species Rarity Confirmed: Never exceeds 4% of total mouse population (highest: TY at 3.356% in 1960)
- EW Growth Pattern: Only region showing significant growth by 1990, more than doubling between 1975-1990
- Continuous Coverage: Source B data ends in 1990, exactly where Source A's timeframe begins (1990-2005), providing 45-year coverage
- Regional Population Peaks: EW shows opposite trends - growth through 1990 in Source B, then 52% decline after 1990 in Source A
- Summary: Historical data reveals highly variable Species X populations across regions, with most experiencing declines except EW which grew dramatically before 1990, confirming Species X's rarity and validating its use as an indicator species
Overall Summary
- Data Coverage: Nearly half a century of continuous Species X population data (1960-2005)
- Rarity Confirmation: Species X consistently represents less than 4% of total mouse populations
- EW Population Peak: Around 1990 - growing dramatically before then declining sharply after
- Accuracy Level: Percentage variation (0.255% to 3.356%) explains why estimates are ""fairly accurate"" rather than precise
- Methodology Validation: Sources together validate using this rare species to estimate total mouse populations across regions
Question Analysis
- Task: Evaluate three statements about the total mouse population of the TY region across different time periods
- Requirements:
- Must evaluate each statement as Yes or No
- Focus specifically on TY region
- Statements concern TOTAL mouse population, not just Species X
- Need to calculate total populations from Species X data and percentages
- Answer Type: Numerical calculation and verification of claims about population changes
Connecting to Our Passage Analysis
- Calculation Required: The analysis doesn't directly address total mouse populations for TY region - must calculate from Species X population and percentage data in Source B tables
- Formula: Total Population = Species X Population ÷ (Percentage ÷ 100)
- Source: Cannot answer from analysis alone - requires calculation using Source B data
Extracting Relevant Findings
- TY Region Data from Source B:
- Species X populations: 1960: 947,630; 1975: 144,520; 1990: 968,460
- Percentages: 1960: 3.356%; 1975: 0.351%; 1990: 2.051%
Statement 1 Evaluation
- Question: Did TY's total mouse population change more between 1960-1975 than between 1975-1990?
- Calculations:
- 1960 total: 947,630 ÷ 0.03356 = 28,236,423
- 1975 total: 144,520 ÷ 0.00351 = 41,188,034
- 1990 total: 968,460 ÷ 0.02051 = 47,219,893
- Change 1960-1975: From 28,236,423 to 41,188,034 = increase of 12,951,611
- Change 1975-1990: From 41,188,034 to 47,219,893 = increase of 6,031,859
- Result: 12,951,611 > 6,031,859
- YES - The population changed more (~13 million increase) from 1960-1975 than from 1975-1990 (~6 million increase)
Statement 2 Evaluation
- Question: Was TY's total mouse population 47 million in 1990 when rounded to the nearest million?
- 1990 total population: 968,460 ÷ 0.02051 = 47,219,893
- Rounded to nearest million: 47,000,000
- YES - The 1990 population of 47,219,893 rounds to 47 million
Statement 3 Evaluation
- Question: Did TY's total mouse population decrease from 1975 to 1990?
- 1975 population: 41,188,034
- 1990 population: 47,219,893
- Comparison: 47,219,893 > 41,188,034 (increased, not decreased)
- NO - The population INCREASED from 41.2 million to 47.2 million, not fell
Calculation Verification
- Formula Check: Species X population divided by percentage as decimal
- 1960: 947,630 ÷ 0.03356 = 28,236,423
- 1975: 144,520 ÷ 0.00351 = 41,188,034
- 1990: 968,460 ÷ 0.02051 = 47,219,893
- All three statements evaluated using calculated totals
- Final Answer: Yes, Yes, No
The total mouse population of TY changed more from 1960 to 1975 than from 1975 to 1990.
Rounded to the nearest million, the total mouse population of TY was 47 million in 1990.
The total mouse population of TY fell from 1975 to 1990.