Lauren wants to assemble a collection of books with fish-themed titles by shopping at her local bookstore. On the bookstore's...
GMAT Table Analysis : (TA) Questions
Lauren wants to assemble a collection of books with fish-themed titles by shopping at her local bookstore. On the bookstore's website, she searched for the keyword fish. The search returned only the results shown in the table. From the copies in stock included in the search results, Lauren purchased a set of books consisting of 5 books with distinct titles from 4 different sections. The total price she paid was the lowest possible for such a set of books.
Title | Author | Format | Section | Copies in stock | Price ($) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Curious George at the Aquarium | Rey, Margaret | used hardcover | children's | 1 | 3.99 |
Curious George Goes Fishing | Rey, A. | new hardcover | children's | 3 | 2.98 |
Eels | Prosek, James | new hardcover | science | 1 | 25.99 |
Fish | Bitbnan, Mark | used hardcover | cooking | 2 | 11 |
Fish | Batman, Mark | new paperback | cooking | 4 | 9.98 |
Float-fishing Strategies | Streeks, E. Neale | new paperback | outdoors | 0 | 19.95 |
Salmon | Morgan, Diane | new paperback | cooking | 2 | 9.98 |
Saving Fish from Drowning | Tan, Amy | used paperback | literature | 6 | 2.63 |
Saving Fish from Drowning | Tan, Amy | new paperback | literature | 1 | 7.98 |
For each of the following titles, select Yes if it must have been a part of Lauren's purchase. Otherwise, select No.
OWNING THE DATASET
Let's start by understanding this dataset strategically. We're looking at a table of books available at a bookstore with information about titles, prices, sections, and stock levels.
Rather than manually scanning row-by-row, let's immediately sort the data in ways that will reveal key insights:
Key Insight #1: When we sort by "Copies in Stock" (ascending), we immediately discover that "Float-fishing Strategies" is the only book with 0 copies available. This will be important for Statement 1.
Key Insight #2: When we sort by "Section", we can instantly see there are only 4 sections represented: children's, cooking, literature, and science. Additionally, we notice:
- Science section has only ONE book ("Eels")
- Cooking section has two books at exactly the same price ($9.98)
- Literature has only one book
- Children's section has two books
The question tells us Lauren needs to purchase 5 books, including at least one from each of the 4 sections. This constraint combined with our section analysis will drive our efficient solution approach.
ANALYZING STATEMENT 3 (Tackling this first based on constraint level)
Statement 3 Translation:
Original: "Eels will be one of the books that Lauren purchases."
What we're looking for:
- Is "Eels" a necessary part of Lauren's purchase?
- Do the constraints force Lauren to buy this specific book?
In other words: Is Lauren required to buy "Eels" based on her purchase constraints?
Let's apply our section-based strategic approach. We already identified that "Eels" is the ONLY book in the science section. Since Lauren must purchase at least one book from each of the 4 sections, and "Eels" is the only science book available, she has no choice but to purchase "Eels."
This is a perfect example of the "Single Available Option in Required Section" pattern. When there's only one book in a required section, that book must be purchased.
Answer to Statement 3: Yes - Lauren must purchase "Eels" to satisfy her requirement of having books from all four sections.
ANALYZING STATEMENT 1 (Tackling second for efficiency)
Statement 1 Translation:
Original: "Float-fishing Strategies will be one of the books that Lauren purchases."
What we're looking for:
- Will Lauren purchase the book "Float-fishing Strategies"?
- Is this book a necessary part of her 5-book purchase?
In other words: Is Lauren required or able to buy "Float-fishing Strategies"?
From our initial dataset analysis where we sorted by "Copies in Stock," we already know that "Float-fishing Strategies" has 0 copies available. This is an example of the "Zero Stock Constraint" pattern - we can immediately determine that Lauren cannot purchase a book that isn't in stock.
No calculation needed - we can answer directly based on our initial sorting insight.
Answer to Statement 1: No - Lauren cannot purchase "Float-fishing Strategies" as it has 0 copies in stock.
ANALYZING STATEMENT 2 (Tackling last as it's least constrained)
Statement 2 Translation:
Original: "Fish will be one of the books that Lauren purchases."
What we're looking for:
- Will Lauren definitely purchase the book titled "Fish"?
- Is this book a necessary part of her 5-book purchase?
In other words: Must Lauren buy "Fish" to satisfy her purchase requirements?
From our section sorting, we discovered that there are two cooking books available: "Fish" and "Salmon," both priced exactly the same at $9.98. This is a classic "Multiple Equal Cost Options" pattern.
Since Lauren only needs one cooking book to satisfy her "one from each section" requirement, she could choose either "Fish" OR "Salmon" - there's nothing forcing her to specifically choose "Fish." Both books are identical in price and would equally satisfy her cooking section requirement.
Answer to Statement 2: No - Lauren might purchase "Fish," but it's not necessarily part of her purchase since she could choose "Salmon" instead.
FINAL ANSWER COMPILATION
Let's verify our answers with a quick logical check of Lauren's purchase constraints:
- She needs 5 books total
- She needs at least one book from each of the 4 sections
Her optimal purchase would include:
- Science section: "Eels" (mandatory - only option)
- Literature section: "Saving Fish from Drowning" (mandatory - only option)
- Cooking section: Either "Fish" OR "Salmon" (same price, either works)
- Children's section: She'll need both Curious George books to reach 5 total books
This confirms our statement evaluations:
- Statement 1: No (Float-fishing Strategies has 0 stock)
- Statement 2: No (Fish isn't necessary - Salmon could be chosen instead)
- Statement 3: Yes (Eels is mandatory as the only science book)
The correct answer is: Statement 3 only
LEARNING SUMMARY
Skills We Used
- Strategic Sorting: We sorted by stock levels and sections immediately to reveal key patterns
- Constraint-First Analysis: We identified the most constrained elements first (the single science book)
- Pattern Recognition: We recognized three common patterns: "Single Available Option," "Zero Stock Constraint," and "Multiple Equal Cost Options"
Strategic Insights
- Reorder Statement Analysis: We tackled statements in order of constraint level (3→1→2), not numerical order
- Sorting as a Superpower: Two simple sorts revealed almost everything we needed without manual checking
- Recognition Over Calculation: We didn't need to calculate prices or totals because we understood the logical constraints
Common Mistakes We Avoided
- Sequential Statement Analysis: Analyzing statements in numerical order would have been less efficient
- Manual Checking: We avoided manually checking each book's section and availability
- Unnecessary Calculations: We didn't need to calculate the exact cost of Lauren's purchase
Remember, in table analysis questions, your first step should always be to consider sorting the data in ways that will reveal patterns and constraints. Look for "single option" scenarios first as they create firm boundaries for your solution.
Float-fishing Strategies
Fish
Eels