Events A, B, and C have the following probabilities of future occurrence: 20% 50% 80%...
GMAT Two Part Analysis : (TPA) Questions
Events A, B, and C have the following probabilities of future occurrence:
- 20%
- 50%
- 80%
On the basis of these probabilities, select for Both A and B a description that must be true of the probability that both A and B will occur. And select for B or C or Both a description that must be true of the probability that B or C or both will occur. Make only two selections, one in each column.
Phase 1: Owning the Dataset
Visualization
Let's create a probability scale to understand the given information:
0% -------- 20% -------- 50% -------- 80% -------- 100% A B C
Given probabilities:
- Event A: 20%
- Event B: 50%
- Event C: 80%
Phase 2: Understanding the Question
We need to find:
- Both A and B: A description that MUST be true of \(\mathrm{P(A \text{ and } B)}\)
- B or C or Both: A description that MUST be true of \(\mathrm{P(B \text{ or } C)}\)
Key Insight for "Both A and B"
The probability of both events occurring depends on their relationship:
- If independent: \(\mathrm{P(A \text{ and } B)} = 0.20 \times 0.50 = 0.10 = 10\%\)
- If A is completely contained in B: \(\mathrm{P(A \text{ and } B)} = \mathrm{P(A)} = 20\%\)
- If B is completely contained in A: Impossible since \(\mathrm{P(B)} > \mathrm{P(A)}\)
- If mutually exclusive: \(\mathrm{P(A \text{ and } B)} = 0\%\)
Since we don't know the relationship, \(\mathrm{P(A \text{ and } B)}\) can range from 0% to 20%.
Key Insight for "B or C or Both"
Using the probability addition rule:
\(\mathrm{P(B \text{ or } C)} = \mathrm{P(B)} + \mathrm{P(C)} - \mathrm{P(B \text{ and } C)}\)
The overlap \(\mathrm{P(B \text{ and } C)}\) determines the final value:
- Maximum \(\mathrm{P(B \text{ or } C)}\): When events don't overlap, \(\mathrm{P(B \text{ and } C)} = 0\)
\(\mathrm{P(B \text{ or } C)} = 50\% + 80\% - 0\% = 130\%\) → But capped at 100% - Minimum \(\mathrm{P(B \text{ or } C)}\): When overlap is maximum (B completely contained in C)
\(\mathrm{P(B \text{ and } C)} = \mathrm{P(B)} = 50\%\)
\(\mathrm{P(B \text{ or } C)} = 50\% + 80\% - 50\% = 80\%\)
Phase 3: Finding the Answer
For "Both A and B"
\(\mathrm{P(A \text{ and } B)}\) must be between 0% and 20%.
Checking answer choices:
- "Must be equal to 40%" ✗ (exceeds maximum of 20%)
- "Must be equal to 50%" ✗ (exceeds maximum of 20%)
- "Must be equal to 70%" ✗ (exceeds maximum of 20%)
- "Must be less than or equal to 20%" ✓ (covers entire possible range)
- "Must be greater than or equal to 80%" ✗ (impossible)
For "B or C or Both"
\(\mathrm{P(B \text{ or } C)}\) must be between 80% and 100%.
Checking answer choices:
- "Must be equal to 40%" ✗ (below minimum of 80%)
- "Must be equal to 50%" ✗ (below minimum of 80%)
- "Must be equal to 70%" ✗ (below minimum of 80%)
- "Must be less than or equal to 20%" ✗ (contradicts minimum of 80%)
- "Must be greater than or equal to 80%" ✓ (covers entire possible range)
Phase 4: Solution
Final Answer:
- Both A and B: Must be less than or equal to 20%
- B or C or Both: Must be greater than or equal to 80%
These selections capture what MUST be true regardless of the specific relationships between the events.