An international basketball tournament will be held in either Nation QN or Nation RN. Exactly six nations, including the host,...
GMAT Two Part Analysis : (TPA) Questions
An international basketball tournament will be held in either Nation QN or Nation RN. Exactly six nations, including the host, plan to participate, depending on the following conditions: SN will participate only if TN does. UN will not participate if either VN or WN does. WN will not participate unless the tournament is held in RN.
Based on the information provided, and assuming WN participates, in the first column select the nation that must also participate, and in the second column select the nation that will not participate. Make only two selections, one in each column.
OWNING THE DATASET
Visual Representation
Nations Pool: QN, RN, SN, TN, UN, VN, WN (Host nation to be determined)
Conditions:
- \(\mathrm{SN} \rightarrow \mathrm{TN}\) (If SN participates, then TN must participate)
- \((\mathrm{VN} \rightarrow \neg\mathrm{UN}) \land (\mathrm{WN} \rightarrow \neg\mathrm{UN})\) (If VN or WN participates, UN cannot)
- \(\mathrm{WN} \rightarrow \mathrm{RN}\) as host (WN participates only if RN hosts)
Given: WN participates
Immediate Inferences
From WN participating:
- Condition 3: \(\mathrm{WN} \rightarrow \mathrm{RN}\), so tournament must be in RN
- Condition 2: \(\mathrm{WN} \rightarrow \neg\mathrm{UN}\), so UN cannot participate
UNDERSTANDING THE QUESTION
Task Analysis
- Select one nation that must participate
- Select one nation that will not participate
- Given constraint: WN participates
PROCESSING THE SOLUTION
Critical Insight
With WN participating, we immediately know:
- RN hosts (from condition 3)
- UN cannot participate (from condition 2)
Strategic Reasoning
Current Status
- Participating: WN (given), RN (host)
- Not participating: UN
- Remaining nations: QN, SN, TN, VN
The Key Deduction
We need exactly 6 nations total:
- 2 already participating (WN, RN)
- 1 definitely not participating (UN)
- 4 spots remaining for exactly 4 remaining nations
Therefore: ALL remaining nations (QN, SN, TN, VN) MUST participate to reach exactly 6.
Verification
Final configuration:
- Participating: WN, RN, QN, SN, TN, VN (6 nations)
- Not participating: UN
This satisfies all conditions:
- check SN participates with TN (Condition 1)
- check UN doesn't participate when WN does (Condition 2)
- check Tournament in RN with WN participating (Condition 3)
- check Exactly 6 nations participate
FINAL SOLUTION SYNTHESIS
Solution Path
- \(\mathrm{WN}\) participates → \(\mathrm{RN}\) must host
- \(\mathrm{WN}\) participates → \(\mathrm{UN}\) cannot participate
- Need exactly 6 nations → All remaining must participate
Final Answer
- Column 1 (Must participate): Any of QN, RN, SN, TN, or VN
- Column 2 (Will not participate): UN
Key Insights
- The "exactly 6 nations" constraint combined with elimination of UN creates a forcing function
- Once we know 2 participate and 1 doesn't, the math dictates all others must participate
- This is a counting problem disguised as a logic puzzle
Exam Strategy
- Look for numerical constraints ("exactly 6") that can force unique solutions
- Chain implications quickly: given fact → immediate consequences → count remaining spots
- When spots equal remaining options, no testing needed—all must fill those spots