Solution: Document Review Chain Analysis
Visual Representation of Supervision Hierarchy
Adiliah
/ \
Bao Davi
|
Laszlo
/ \
Saleema Yarah
Understanding the Review Process
Key Rules:
- Initial review: Exactly one department member
- Chain rule: Each reviewer's supervisor must also review
- No extras: Only required reviewers participate
- Chain continues: Until reaching someone with no supervisor
Part 1: Maximum Reviewers with Laszlo
Possible Scenarios:
- Laszlo initiates
- Review chain: Laszlo → Davi → Adiliah
- Total reviewers: 3
- Saleema or Yarah initiates
- Review chain: Saleema/Yarah → Laszlo → Davi → Adiliah
- Total reviewers: 4
Critical Insight:
To maximize reviewers when Laszlo is included, start the chain from someone Laszlo supervises. This creates the longest possible chain through the hierarchy.
Maximum with Laszlo: 4 reviewers
Part 2: Maximum Reviewers with Adiliah
Key Constraint:
Adiliah has no supervisor, so she cannot initiate a review (no one would review after her).
Possible Chains Ending at Adiliah:
From Bao: Bao → Adiliah (2 reviewers)
From Davi: Davi → Adiliah (2 reviewers)
From Laszlo: Laszlo → Davi → Adiliah (3 reviewers)
From Saleema/Yarah: Saleema/Yarah → Laszlo → Davi → Adiliah (4 reviewers)
Critical Insight:
The longest chain to Adiliah starts from the bottom of the hierarchy (Saleema or Yarah), creating a 4-person review chain.
Maximum with Adiliah: 4 reviewers
Final Answer
- Laszlo among reviewers: Select 4
- Adiliah among reviewers: Select 4
Key Exam Strategy
For hierarchy-based TPA questions:
- Visualize the structure immediately
- Identify chain patterns - reviews flow upward
- Find extremes logically - longest chains start from the bottom
- Skip exhaustive testing - once you identify the pattern, apply it directly