According to a certain nation's postal regulation, a package in a rectangular shipping box qualifies for express shipping only if...
GMAT Two Part Analysis : (TPA) Questions
According to a certain nation's postal regulation, a package in a rectangular shipping box qualifies for express shipping only if its two smallest dimensions do not exceed 20 centimeters and 40 centimeters, respectively. A particular rectangular shipping box with dimensions \(\mathrm{L, W, and H}\), in centimeters, where \(\mathrm{LWH = 18,000}\) and \(\mathrm{L \geq W \geq H}\), qualifies for express shipping. Given that one of the box's dimensions is 20 centimeters
select for \(\mathrm{L}\) and for \(\mathrm{W}\) measurements, in centimenters, that could be the length and the width of the box, jointly consistent with the information. Make only two selections, one in each column.
Phase 1: Owning the Dataset
Understanding the Constraints
We have a rectangular shipping box with dimensions L, W, and H (in centimeters) where:
- \(\mathrm{L} ≥ \mathrm{W} ≥ \mathrm{H}\) (ordered from largest to smallest)
- \(\mathrm{L} × \mathrm{W} × \mathrm{H} = 18,000\) (volume constraint)
- One dimension equals 20 cm
- Box qualifies for express shipping
For express shipping, the two smallest dimensions must not exceed 20 cm and 40 cm respectively. Since \(\mathrm{L} ≥ \mathrm{W} ≥ \mathrm{H}\), the two smallest dimensions are W and H.
Therefore: \(\mathrm{H} ≤ 20\) and \(\mathrm{W} ≤ 40\)
Visual Representation
Let's create a simple diagram showing our dimension relationships:
L (largest) ≥ W (middle) ≥ H (smallest) ↓ ↓ ≤ 40 cm ≤ 20 cm L × W × H = 18,000
Phase 2: Understanding the Question
We need to select values for L and W from the choices [10, 18, 20, 30, 36] that could represent the length and width of this box.
Key Insight
Since one dimension is 20 cm and we have the ordering \(\mathrm{L} ≥ \mathrm{W} ≥ \mathrm{H}\), let's determine which dimension equals 20.
Phase 3: Finding the Answer
Case Analysis
Case 1: If H = 20
- Since H = 20, we have \(\mathrm{H} ≤ 20\) ✓ (express shipping requirement satisfied)
- From \(\mathrm{L} × \mathrm{W} × \mathrm{H} = 18,000\): \(\mathrm{L} × \mathrm{W} × 20 = 18,000\)
- Therefore: \(\mathrm{L} × \mathrm{W} = 900\)
- We need: \(\mathrm{L} ≥ \mathrm{W} ≥ 20\) and \(\mathrm{W} ≤ 40\)
Checking combinations from our choices:
- If W = 30, then \(\mathrm{L} = 900 ÷ 30 = 30\)
- Check: Is \(30 ≥ 30 ≥ 20\)? Yes ✓
- Check: Is \(\mathrm{W} = 30 ≤ 40\)? Yes ✓
- This works! L = 30, W = 30
? Stop here - we found our answer.
Quick verification of other cases:
- Case 2 (W = 20): Would require \(\mathrm{L} × \mathrm{H} = 900\) with \(\mathrm{H} ≤ 20\), but no valid combinations exist
- Case 3 (L = 20): Would require \(\mathrm{W} × \mathrm{H} = 900\) with both W, H ≤ 20, which is impossible since \(20 × 20 = 400 < 900\)
Phase 4: Solution
Our analysis shows that H = 20 cm, and the only valid combination from the given choices is:
- L = 30 cm
- W = 30 cm
This satisfies all requirements:
- \(\mathrm{L} ≥ \mathrm{W} ≥ \mathrm{H}\): \(30 ≥ 30 ≥ 20\) ✓
- Volume: \(30 × 30 × 20 = 18,000\) ✓
- Express shipping: \(\mathrm{H} = 20 ≤ 20\) ✓ and \(\mathrm{W} = 30 ≤ 40\) ✓