A certain company has the following policy regarding membership in committees A, B, C: each of the committees have exactly...
GMAT Two Part Analysis : (TPA) Questions
A certain company has the following policy regarding membership in committees A, B, C: each of the committees have exactly 40 members, and each employee must be a member of at least one of the committees. The company currently has 110 employees.
Let \(\mathrm{X}\) be the current number of employees who are members of more than one of the committees. Based on the current total number of employees, select the least value of \(\mathrm{X}\) that is compatible with the policy and select the greatest value of \(\mathrm{X}\) that is compatible with the policy.
Let's visualize this problem to make it crystal clear...
Phase 1: Owning the Dataset
Visualization Selection
This is a set membership problem, so I'll use a Venn diagram approach with careful accounting.
Total Committee Memberships = \(40 + 40 + 40 = 120\)
Total Employees = \(110\)
Key insight: Since there are 120 total memberships but only 110 employees, some employees must be counted multiple times (in multiple committees).
Setting Up the Problem
Let me denote:
- Employees in exactly 1 committee = \(110 - \mathrm{X}\)
- Employees in more than 1 committee = \(\mathrm{X}\)
Since each person in multiple committees creates extra "membership counts":
- Someone in 2 committees counts as 2 memberships
- Someone in 3 committees counts as 3 memberships
Phase 2: Understanding the Question
Using Inclusion-Exclusion Principle
For sets A, B, C with \(|\mathrm{A}| = |\mathrm{B}| = |\mathrm{C}| = 40\):
\(|\mathrm{A} \cup \mathrm{B} \cup \mathrm{C}| = 110\) (total employees)
By inclusion-exclusion:
\(110 = 120 - |\mathrm{A} \cap \mathrm{B}| - |\mathrm{A} \cap \mathrm{C}| - |\mathrm{B} \cap \mathrm{C}| + |\mathrm{A} \cap \mathrm{B} \cap \mathrm{C}|\)
Rearranging:
\(|\mathrm{A} \cap \mathrm{B}| + |\mathrm{A} \cap \mathrm{C}| + |\mathrm{B} \cap \mathrm{C}| - |\mathrm{A} \cap \mathrm{B} \cap \mathrm{C}| = 10\)
Key Relationship
The number of employees in more than one committee is:
\(\mathrm{X} = |\mathrm{A} \cap \mathrm{B}| + |\mathrm{A} \cap \mathrm{C}| + |\mathrm{B} \cap \mathrm{C}| - 2|\mathrm{A} \cap \mathrm{B} \cap \mathrm{C}|\)
Let me denote \(|\mathrm{A} \cap \mathrm{B} \cap \mathrm{C}| = \mathrm{a}\)
Since \(|\mathrm{A} \cap \mathrm{B}| + |\mathrm{A} \cap \mathrm{C}| + |\mathrm{B} \cap \mathrm{C}| = 10 + \mathrm{a}\):
\(\mathrm{X} = (10 + \mathrm{a}) - 2\mathrm{a} = 10 - \mathrm{a}\)
Phase 3: Finding the Answer
Finding the Range of X
Since \(\mathrm{X} = 10 - \mathrm{a}\), we need the range of a (employees in all 3 committees).
Maximum value of a:
Each pairwise intersection must be at least a, so:
\(|\mathrm{A} \cap \mathrm{B}| + |\mathrm{A} \cap \mathrm{C}| + |\mathrm{B} \cap \mathrm{C}| \geq 3\mathrm{a}\)
But we know this sum equals \(10 + \mathrm{a}\), so:
\(10 + \mathrm{a} \geq 3\mathrm{a}\)
\(10 \geq 2\mathrm{a}\)
\(\mathrm{a} \leq 5\)
Minimum value of a:
Clearly \(\mathrm{a} \geq 0\) (can't be negative)
Verifying Feasibility
For minimum X (when a = 5):
- \(\mathrm{X} = 10 - 5 = 5\)
- All 5 are in all three committees
- The remaining 105 employees are each in exactly one committee
- Each committee needs 35 more members (\(40 - 5 = 35\))
- Total single-committee members needed: \(3 \times 35 = 105\) ✓
For maximum X (when a = 0):
- \(\mathrm{X} = 10 - 0 = 10\)
- No one is in all three committees
- 10 employees are in exactly 2 committees
- 100 employees are in exactly 1 committee
This can be distributed (for example):
- 5 in A∩B only
- 3 in A∩C only
- 2 in B∩C only
- Plus 100 in single committees
Phase 4: Solution
The least value of \(\mathrm{X} = 5\)
The greatest value of \(\mathrm{X} = 10\)
Both values appear in our answer choices, confirming our solution.