A certain city's bus system includes several stops within a University campus. The city has devised a new plan to...
GMAT Graphics Interpretation : (GI) Questions

A certain city's bus system includes several stops within a University campus. The city has devised a new plan to decrease the amount of time bus drivers devote to receiving payments at the busy University stops. Under the new plan, outlined in the diagram, passengers would pay upon entry, pay upon exit, or ride free, depending on the time of day, on their boarding and departure locations, and on whether they present a valid University student identification card (ID).
Select from each drop-down menu the option that creates the most accurate statement based on the information provided.
Owning the Dataset
Table 1: Text Analysis
Text Component | Literal Content | Simple Interpretation |
---|---|---|
System Description | A certain city's bus system includes several stops within a University campus. | The bus system serves both city and campus areas. |
Problem Addressed | The city has devised a new plan to decrease the amount of time bus drivers devote to receiving payments at busy University stops. | New fare rules are meant to speed up payments at university stops. |
Fare Payment Methods | Passengers would pay upon entry, pay upon exit, or ride free, depending on ... various conditions as outlined in the diagram. | There are three possible outcomes: pay on entry, pay on exit, or ride free. |
Determining Conditions | Conditions include time of day, boarding and departure locations, and valid University student identification card (ID). | Whether, where, and when passengers board/exit, and if student ID is shown, matter. |
Table 2: Chart Analysis
Chart Component | Details | Implication |
---|---|---|
Initial Decision | Boarded between 6:00 a.m. and 6:00 p.m.? | Time of boarding is the first critical branch. |
Student ID Check | If during the day, shown student ID? | Valid student ID leads directly to riding free. |
Boarding Location Check | If no student ID, boarded at University stop? | Only passengers at University stops proceed to next decision. |
Departure Location Check | If yes, exiting at University stop? | Exiting at University stop gives ride free, otherwise pay on exit. |
Payment Outcomes | Terminal nodes: pay on entry, pay on exit, or ride free. | All passengers end at one payment outcome according to their path. |
Key Insights
- Carrying a valid University student ID during daytime always grants a free ride, making location irrelevant for those passengers.
- Passengers without student IDs who board and exit at University stops during daytime can also ride free, but those exiting elsewhere must pay on exit.
- Outside 6:00 a.m.–6:00 p.m., everyone must pay upon entry regardless of ID or location, greatly simplifying fare collection in off-peak hours.
Step-by-Step Solution
Question 1: Identifying the Required Payment Outcome
Complete Statement:
According to the diagram, under the new plan, if a bus passenger [BLANK 1], then that passenger must not have [BLANK 2].
Breaking Down the Statement
- Statement Breakdown 1:
- Key Phrase: if a bus passenger [BLANK 1]
Meaning: The statement refers to a specific fare payment result a passenger experiences according to the flowchart.
Relation to Chart: The chart shows three possible payment outcomes: rides free, pays on entry, pays on exit.
Important Implications: We must match a payment outcome to a unique 'must not have' condition.
- Key Phrase: if a bus passenger [BLANK 1]
- Statement Breakdown 2:
- Key Phrase: must not have [BLANK 2]
Meaning: We're seeking a requirement that a certain condition was NOT met for that outcome.
Relation to Chart: Each terminal node in the flowchart can only be reached if certain conditions (including not meeting some) are followed.
Important Implications: Only one payment outcome will have a single, specific 'must not have' requirement.
- Key Phrase: must not have [BLANK 2]
- What is needed: Which payment outcome (rides free, pays on entry, pays on exit) is only possible if a condition is not met, enabling us to fill in both blanks.
Solution:
- Condensed Solution Implementation:
Trace all paths leading to each payment outcome and list the mandatory conditions. Identify if any outcome can only be reached if a passenger has NOT satisfied a required condition. 'Pays on exit' is uniquely possible only when the passenger did NOT present a valid University student ID. Therefore, 'pays on exit' must go in the first blank. - Necessary Data points:
There is only one way to 'pays on exit': board between 6am–6pm, NOT present Student ID, board at University stop, and exit at a non-University stop. The other outcomes do not have a necessary single exclusion.- Calculations Estimations:
No numerical calculations needed—just logical deduction by process tracing. - Comparison to Answer Choices:
Rides free and pays on entry can be reached via multiple paths that do not rely on a single 'must not have.' Only 'pays on exit' requires that the passenger must NOT have presented a valid University student ID.
- Calculations Estimations:
FINAL ANSWER Blank 1: pays on exit
Question 2: Determining the Prohibited Action
Complete Statement:
According to the diagram, under the new plan, if a bus passenger pays on exit, then that passenger must not have [BLANK 2].
Breaking Down the Statement
- Statement Breakdown 1:
- Key Phrase: pays on exit
Meaning: The conclusion of the chart's path is the 'pays on exit' terminal node.
Relation to Chart: Only one specific path leads to 'pays on exit' in the chart.
- Key Phrase: pays on exit
- Statement Breakdown 2:
- Key Phrase: must not have [BLANK 2]
Meaning: We are looking for the specific prerequisite that must be false to reach 'pays on exit.'
Relation to Chart: Along the only route to 'pays on exit', the student must have answered 'No' to presenting a valid University student ID.
- Key Phrase: must not have [BLANK 2]
- What is needed: What condition must be false (i.e., NOT have presented) for someone to end up paying on exit according to the diagram.
Solution:
- Condensed Solution Implementation:
Follow the flowchart starting from boarding between 6am–6pm, then follow the 'No' route at presenting student ID, then 'Yes' for boarding at University stop, and 'No' for exiting at University stop. The critical decision is 'No' to presenting a valid University student ID. - Necessary Data points:
The route: board between 6am–6pm -> NOT present student ID -> board at University stop -> NOT exit at University stop = pays on exit.- Calculations Estimations:
No calculation required; the 'No' to presenting the ID is pivotal. - Comparison to Answer Choices:
Out of the available conditions, only presenting a valid University student ID must be absolutely false for the 'pays on exit' path.
- Calculations Estimations:
FINAL ANSWER Blank 2: presented a valid University student ID
Summary
To fill both blanks, the solution traces all possible terminal outcomes in the fare flowchart. Only 'pays on exit' can be reached exclusively by not presenting a valid University student ID, so these are the answers that fit the statement's logic according to the diagram.
Question Independence Analysis
The questions are dependent: determining the correct outcome for Blank 1 (pays on exit) immediately restricts the possible answer for Blank 2 (must not have presented a valid University student ID), since only that combination is uniquely constrained according to the flowchart.